New managers handling underperformers in Google teams must initiate the Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) process promptly. The first steps involve documenting performance issues, setting clear goals, and establishing a timeline. A successful PIP requires a structured approach, focusing on specific behaviors rather than personality traits.
TL;DR
New managers handling underperformers in Google teams must initiate the Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) process promptly. The first steps involve documenting performance issues, setting clear goals, and establishing a timeline. A successful PIP requires a structured approach, focusing on specific behaviors rather than personality traits.
Not sure what to bring up in your next 1:1? The 0→1 PM Interview Playbook (2026 Edition) has 30+ high-signal questions organized by goal.
Who This Is For
This article is for new managers in Google teams who are tasked with handling underperforming team members. It is particularly relevant for those in technical and product management roles, such as Google PMs, who are responsible for leading cross-functional teams and driving project goals.
What Are the Initial Steps in Google's PIP Process?
The initial steps in Google's PIP process involve identifying performance issues, documenting specific examples, and setting clear goals for improvement. A new manager must gather data on the underperformer's current performance, including metrics and feedback from peers. For instance, in a Google team, a manager might review project timelines, code quality metrics, and peer feedback to identify areas for improvement.
How Do I Document Performance Issues Effectively?
Effective documentation of performance issues involves specific examples, measurable data, and a clear description of the expected behavior. A new manager should focus on behaviors rather than personality traits, ensuring the feedback is actionable and fair. For example, instead of stating "John is not a team player," a manager might say, "John has not been actively contributing to team discussions, with only 2 out of 10 meeting attendances in the past quarter."
What Are the Key Components of a PIP Goal?
A PIP goal should be specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, and time-bound (SMART). For a Google PM, a PIP goal might involve improving project delivery timelines or enhancing product quality metrics. The goal should be challenging yet attainable, with a clear timeline for achievement. For instance, a PIP goal might state, "Improve project delivery timelines by 30% within the next 6 weeks, with bi-weekly check-ins to track progress."
How Do I Establish a Timeline for PIP Completion?
Establishing a timeline for PIP completion involves setting realistic milestones and check-in points. A new manager should work with the underperformer to establish a timeline that allows for regular feedback and progress tracking. For example, a 6-week PIP timeline might include bi-weekly check-ins, with specific milestones for progress evaluation.
What Is the Role of Regular Feedback in the PIP Process?
Regular feedback is crucial in the PIP process, providing the underperformer with ongoing guidance and support. A new manager should schedule regular check-ins to discuss progress, provide feedback, and adjust the PIP plan as needed. For instance, a manager might hold weekly 1-on-1 meetings with the underperformer to discuss progress and provide feedback.
Preparation Checklist
To effectively handle an underperformer in a Google team, a new manager should:
- Review Google's PIP process guidelines and templates
- Gather data on the underperformer's current performance, including metrics and feedback
- Set clear, SMART goals for improvement
- Establish a timeline for PIP completion with regular check-in points
- Work through a structured preparation system (the PM Interview Playbook covers Google's performance management framework with real debrief examples)
- Communicate the PIP plan clearly to the underperformer and relevant stakeholders
Mistakes to Avoid
When handling an underperformer in a Google team, new managers should avoid:
- Being too vague or general in documenting performance issues (BAD: "John is not doing well"; GOOD: "John has missed 3 project deadlines in the past quarter, resulting in delayed project timelines")
- Focusing on personality traits rather than specific behaviors (BAD: "John is not a team player"; GOOD: "John has not been actively contributing to team discussions")
- Not providing regular feedback and progress tracking (BAD: Providing feedback only at the end of the PIP timeline; GOOD: Scheduling bi-weekly check-ins to track progress)
FAQ
Q: What is the typical duration of a PIP at Google?
A: The duration of a PIP at Google varies, but it is typically 6-12 weeks, with regular check-in points to track progress.
Q: Can an underperformer appeal the PIP decision?
A: Yes, an underperformer can appeal the PIP decision through Google's HR process, which involves reviewing the PIP plan and providing additional feedback.
Q: What happens if an underperformer fails to meet PIP goals?
A: If an underperformer fails to meet PIP goals, the manager may need to consider further action, including termination or reassignment, in accordance with Google's HR policies.
Ready to build a real interview prep system?
Get the full PM Interview Prep System →
The book is also available on Amazon Kindle.