First-Time Manager: How to Handle an Underperformer on Your Google Team Without Burning Bridges

What is the Most Effective Way to Address Underperformance on a Google Team?

Handling underperformance requires a structured approach, focusing on clear communication and measurable goals, to avoid burning bridges, which is crucial for first-time managers at Google.

In a recent debrief, a hiring manager emphasized the importance of addressing underperformance promptly, citing a scenario where an engineer's lack of progress on a critical project resulted in a 30-day delay, impacting the entire team's performance. The manager's approach involved setting specific, measurable goals and providing regular feedback, which ultimately led to the engineer's improvement.

This experience highlights the need for first-time managers to develop a systematic method for addressing underperformance, which can be learned through experience and guidance from more senior managers. For instance, Google's manager training program focuses on developing these skills, with a 6-month timeline for new managers to demonstrate proficiency.

How Do I Identify the Root Cause of Underperformance on My Team?

Identifying the root cause of underperformance involves analyzing data, observing behavior, and conducting regular check-ins, which helps first-time managers at Google to develop targeted strategies for improvement, such as providing additional training or resources, with a focus on enhancing skills within a 90-day period.

A key insight from a recent conversation with a Google engineering manager is that underperformance often stems from a lack of clear expectations or insufficient feedback, rather than a lack of skill or motivation.

This understanding is critical for first-time managers, as it allows them to address the root cause effectively, using tools such as Google's performance management framework, which outlines a step-by-step process for setting goals, providing feedback, and evaluating progress. By focusing on these aspects, managers can help underperforming team members get back on track, with a notable example being a team that saw a 25% increase in productivity after implementing a more structured feedback system.

📖 Related: Google vs Meta PM Interview: How Product Sense Questions Differ and How to Prepare

What Are the Key Steps in Creating a Performance Improvement Plan for an Underperformer?

Creating a performance improvement plan involves setting specific goals, establishing a timeline, and providing regular feedback, which is essential for first-time managers at Google to ensure underperformers understand expectations and can work towards improvement, with a typical plan spanning 60 to 90 days.

In developing such a plan, it's crucial to focus on measurable outcomes, such as completing a certain number of tasks within a set timeframe or achieving specific quality standards. For example, a plan might include completing 3 critical tasks within 30 days, with weekly check-ins to review progress and provide feedback.

This structured approach helps underperformers understand what is expected of them and allows managers to assess progress objectively, using data and feedback to adjust the plan as needed. Additionally, leveraging resources such as the PM Interview Playbook, which covers performance management and feedback strategies, can provide valuable insights and templates for creating effective improvement plans.

How Can I Balance Supporting an Underperformer with Meeting Team Performance Goals?

Balancing support for an underperformer with team performance goals requires prioritizing tasks, delegating effectively, and maintaining open communication, which first-time managers at Google must master to ensure team success while helping underperformers improve, often within a tight 6-month performance evaluation cycle.

A common pitfall is spending too much time on underperformers at the expense of other team members, which can lead to resentment and decreased overall team performance.

To avoid this, first-time managers should prioritize tasks based on urgency and impact, delegate responsibilities to other team members when possible, and maintain open lines of communication to ensure everyone is aware of the plan and their roles in supporting the underperformer. This balanced approach not only helps the underperformer but also ensures the team meets its goals, such as achieving a quarterly target of completing 12 projects with a 95% satisfaction rate from stakeholders.

📖 Related: Google L5 vs Meta E5 Total Comp for PMs in 2025

Preparation Checklist

To effectively handle underperformers without burning bridges, first-time managers at Google should:

  • Set clear, measurable goals and expectations
  • Establish a regular feedback loop, including weekly or bi-weekly check-ins
  • Provide specific, actionable feedback focused on behavior and outcomes
  • Develop a performance improvement plan with a clear timeline, such as 60 or 90 days
  • Leverage resources such as the PM Interview Playbook, which covers performance management and feedback strategies with real debrief examples
  • Prioritize tasks and delegate effectively to balance supporting the underperformer with meeting team goals
  • Maintain open communication with the team to ensure everyone is aligned and supportive

Mistakes to Avoid

BAD: Ignoring underperformance or delaying addressing it, which can lead to further deterioration in performance and team morale.

GOOD: Addressing underperformance promptly and systematically, focusing on clear communication, measurable goals, and regular feedback.

Another common mistake is not providing enough support or resources, such as training or mentorship, which can hinder the underperformer's ability to improve. In contrast, providing tailored support and resources can significantly enhance the effectiveness of the performance improvement plan, such as offering a 3-month mentorship program or additional training sessions.

FAQ

Q: What is the average timeline for seeing improvement in an underperformer at Google?

A: The average timeline can vary, but significant improvement is often expected within 90 days, with regular check-ins and feedback.

Q: How often should I provide feedback to an underperformer?

A: Feedback should be provided regularly, such as weekly or bi-weekly, to ensure the underperformer is on track to meet the goals outlined in the performance improvement plan.

Q: What resources are available to help first-time managers at Google develop their performance management skills?

A: Resources include Google's manager training program, the PM Interview Playbook, and mentorship opportunities, all of which can provide valuable insights and strategies for effectively managing underperformers and improving team performance.amazon.com/dp/B0GWWJQ2S3).

Related Reading

What is the Most Effective Way to Address Underperformance on a Google Team?